Envisioning
Ministry for the Future
September 3, 2004
Pastoral
Letter to the Clergy, Religious and Lay Faithful of the Diocese
of Pittsburgh
Dear Sisters
and Brothers in Christ:
Envisioning ministry for the future is one of the challenges we
face in the Diocese of Pittsburgh as we move into the new millennium
aware of the circumstances of our day. It is necessary for us
to address together how qualified and effective pastoral ministry
can continue in this local Church with fewer priests today than
we had two decades ago and, therefore, with greater demands and
responsibilities placed on them.
The August
6, 2004 issue of the Pittsburgh Catholic published my pastoral
message “Fewer Priests, Not Necessarily Less Ministry”
where I spoke of envisioning our needs, and what that means in
terms of fewer priests available for pastoral ministry. Earlier,
in December 2003, the Pittsburgh Catholic carried a feature article
highlighting this concern. This same issue has been the subject
of discussion at the Priest Council and the Diocesan Pastoral
Council. It has also formed the topic of conversation a number
of times at deanery meetings throughout the diocese beginning
last February. As I have visited parishes this same concern has
been expressed by many of the lay faithful.
Since 1992
our diocesan priests have convened every three years for a multi-day
convocation to address significant issues related to priestly
ministry, solidarity and spirituality. These convocations afford
the priests an opportunity to discuss in an environment of mutual
concern such issues as preaching, collaborative ministry in the
Church, responsible and effective pastoral leadership, promoting
priestly vocations and forming a priestly identity in the likeness
of the Good Shepherd.
From September 27 through 30 the triennial multi-day convocation
of priests will be held at Oglebay Resort and Conference Center
in Wheeling, West Virginia, to discuss the many dimensions of
priestly ministry and to envision pastoral ministry for the future
in our diocese. This discussion will include the necessary collaboration
of lay faithful, the needs associated with less priests in our
diocese, and better ways to exercise pastoral ministry in light
of present day challenges.
The 2004 convocation
is the first major step in a diocesan-wide consultation that will
involve priests and deacons, religious and lay leadership in parishes,
and strategy sessions at the deanery level to examine how we will
continue to provide effective ministry in the future. At the conclusion
of the multi-day convocation each deanery in the diocese will
study ways to enhance pastoral ministry. Out of that reflection
will come proposals tailored to meet the needs and resources of
each deanery throughout the diocese.
Steps
Already Taken
Much has already been done to address the needs of our diocesan
Church. In four of my earlier pastoral letters, New Beginnings
(1988), Renew the Face of the Earth (1989), Future Directions
(1993) and Building the City of God (1994) reflections were offered
about the challenge of living our Catholic faith in the realities
present in Southwestern Pennsylvania.
Fifteen years
ago we began the diocesan-wide parish reorganization/revitalization
process which combined and reduced the number of parishes in some
areas. In 1990 we created the Institute for Ministries which made
leadership formation available to the nearly 40,000 lay faithful
involved in ministry. Resources, including the “Lay Ministries
Handbook for Parishes and Institutions” (1994) and a “Hiring
Handbook” (1999), have proved useful for maintaining qualified
and effective ministry.
In 1995, parish
revitalization efforts which focused on spiritual and pastoral
renewal included the production of the “Parish Resource
Manual” that identifies all the elements necessary for vibrant
and healthy parishes; the “Handbook for Deans” which
is a useful tool for evaluating the ministerial quality of parishes,
and the “Policies for Financing Elementary Schools”
that redistributed the cost of Catholic education throughout the
diocese. In the following year the diocese implemented the program
“A Future Full of Hope: A National Strategy for Vocations
to the Priesthood and Religious Life in the Dioceses and Archdioceses
of the United States” which helped parishes develop initiatives
to promote priestly vocations.
The renewal
of the permanent diaconate continued in our diocese with an ordination
class of 33 deacons who completed a formation process that began
in 1995 and concluded in 1999. The diocesan office for the diaconate
is currently finalizing a proposal for future ordination classes
as we await final approval from Rome of the United States Bishops’
directory for the diaconate.
A very significant
part of the renewal of the diocese in its structures and ministry
took place during the 19th Diocesan Synod that convened from Pentecost
1999 through Pentecost 2000. Goals, recommendations and statutes
were implemented as a result of the Synod to guarantee effective
and quality ministry. Concomitant with the preparation for the
Synod was a clergy distribution study (1998-1999) which identified
projections and statistics regarding the number of diocesan priests
in the future and the deanery planning project (2000-2001) that
studied how ministry was being carried out in each deanery in
the diocese. In 2002, the diocesan-wide parish-based stewardship
initiative was created to assist parishes in the development of
programs to support effective and qualified ministry.
All of this
served as remote preparation for the process on which we will
reflect at the multi-day clergy convocation. The more recent efforts
to respond to the circumstances of our day include the establishment
of an ad hoc committee to examine some of the issues raised by
individual parishes and deaneries in 2003 and during my visit
to each of the deaneries in February of 2004. This was followed
by a visit to each deanery by the clergy office to review the
current situation as expressed by the priests so that we could
more adequately prepare for this September multi-day convocation.
Who
We Are as Church
As we begin this consultation it is essential that we do so in
light of who we are as Christ’s Church and what it is that
he has established as his new Body. Fundamental to an understanding
of the Catholic Church is the recognition that Christ established
it according to his will and that baptism is the sacrament of
faith by which one becomes a part of the new Body of Christ and
a member of his Church. At the same time Christ instituted the
priesthood to continue his unique ministry as head of his Church.
Thus we find in baptism our configuration to Christ as a member
of his body, in ordination to the diaconate a configuration to
Christ as servant, and in ordination to priesthood and its fullness
in the episcopate a configuration to Christ as head of his Church.
Baptism
and Mission
When we reflect on ministry, initiatives that support programs,
and our role in building up the kingdom, it is important that
we remember our relationship to one another and to God as members
of his Church. As Christians our primordial identity as believers
is found in the sacrament of baptism. This sacrament incorporates
the person into the Body of Christ giving a share in God’s
life. The early Church understood from the outset the necessity
of baptism for membership in the Church. The writings of Saint
Peter and Saint Paul as recorded in the New Testament speak to
us about being reborn in Christ, becoming a new creation, receiving
the Spirit into our hearts (Gal 6:15; 2 Cor 5:17; 1 Peter 1:23;
1 Cor 12:13; Rom 8:15-16). On the day of Pentecost, for example,
Peter preaches to the crowd: “Repent and be baptized every
one of you in the name of Jesus Christ for the forgiveness of
your sins” (Acts 2:38).
The Catechism
of the Catholic Church reminds us that in baptism one is not only
purified from all sins but made “a new creature, an adopted
son of God, who has become a partaker of the divine nature, member
of Christ and co-heir with him, and a temple of the Holy Spirit”
(1265). From the baptismal fonts is born “the one People
of God of the New Covenant which transcends all the natural or
human limits of nations, cultures, races and sexes” (1267).
“Reborn as sons of God the baptized must profess before
men the faith they have received from God through the Church and
participate in the apostolic and missionary activity of the People
of God” (1270).
Role
of the Laity
All of the baptized are called to share their talent, time and
treasure in building up the Church. In the priestly, prophetic
and kingly dignity which characterizes the baptized, all members
of Christ’s body have their own responsibility and role
in carrying out the mission of the Church. It is in this complementarity
of vocations, charisms and ministries that the Body of Christ
is strengthened.
In his vision
for the beginning of the new millennium, our Holy Father, Pope
John Paul II, spoke of the diversity–in–unity that
marks the Body of Christ. He then recognized the variety of ministries
serving the Church and the world. In his letter Novo Millennio
Ineunte he wrote: “The unity of the Church is not uniformity,
but an organic blending of legitimate diversities. It is the reality
of many members joined in a single body, the one Body of Christ
(cf. 1 Cor. 12.12). Therefore the Church of the third millennium
will need to encourage all the baptized and confirmed to be aware
of their active responsibility in the Church’s life. Together
with the ordained ministry, other ministries, whether formally
instituted or simply recognized, can flourish for the good of
the whole community, sustaining it in all its many needs: from
catechesis to liturgy, from the education of the young to the
widest array of charitable works” (46).
Consecrated
Life
Some of the faithful are called to manifest in religious life
the outpouring of God’s gifts on the Church. Our Holy Father
in the post-synodal apostolic exhortation Vita Consecrata, The
Consecrated Life, speaks of the religious life as a call from
God “to show that the Incarnate Son of God is the eschatological
goal towards which all things tend, the splendor before which
every other light pales, and the infinite beauty which alone can
fully satisfy the human heart” (16).
The same
document reminds us that in the consecrated life “it is
not only a matter of following Christ with one’s whole heart,
of loving him ‘more than father or mother, more than son
or daughter’ (cf. Mt. 10.37) – for this is required
of every disciple—but of living and expressing this by conforming
one’s whole existence to Christ in an all-encompassing commitment
which foreshadows the eschatological perfection, to the extent
that this is possible in time and in accordance with the different
charism” (16).
The
Ministerial Priesthood
The Church has understood from the time of Jesus Christ that some
are called from among the faithful to minister to the whole Body.
Christ, at the Last Supper, instituted the ministerial priesthood
as a distinct sacrament; thus the priesthood of the ordained is
different from the priesthood of the baptized. This sacrament
of holy orders allows one to participate in Christ’s mission
in a unique way. It makes the recipient an authentic, authoritative
and special representative of Christ the head of the Church.
Saint Paul
points out that the Holy Spirit is the source of the division
of labor in the Church and that the offices are quite distinct
(cf. 1. Cor. 12.4-11; Rom. 12.4-8). The division of work follows
a design set by God. Some are called to serve as priests, others
to serve in different roles – but all are called to build
up the Church of Christ (cf. 1. Cor. 12.27-31).
Christ is
the true, invisible head of his body which is the Church. Yet
just as the Body of Christ is made visible and manifest in all
the members throughout the world, so too is it manifest in the
presence of Christ the head of the Church specifically in the
priesthood which carries on the ministry of Christ as head of
his body the Church.
Priest:
Teacher and Pastor
The first task of the priest is to preach the Gospel. Each believer
– disciple – is obliged to preach the Gospel. What
distinguishes the priest’s role is that he participates
in the priestly office authenticating the proclamation as truly
the witness and message of the Church. He is the spokesman for
the living tradition that, guided by the Holy Spirit, presents
and applies for us today the Word of God made flesh in Jesus Christ.
The priest
is prophet and pastor. He stands in the midst of the faith community
as the good shepherd whose voice is recognized as that of Christ.
For this reason, his proclamation of the truth from the pulpit
is balanced by his compassionate care of the flock when they come
for counseling and sacramental confession. It is not an exaggeration
when the Church says that as the priest proclaims the teaching
of the Church, he speaks with the voice of Christ.
Priest:
Leader and Shepherd
The second work of the priest is to lead or shepherd the faithful.
The priest is to facilitate the building of Christian community
among those he serves. Today this takes on a special meaning because
it is precisely in the area of building community that much of
the re-dimensioning of priesthood is taking place.
To build a
Christian community is one of the functions of the priest because
it was one of the priestly works of Christ and was passed on to
his Church as a continuing obligation. However the priest is not
the sole person responsible for carrying out all the details in
building up the faith community. With the emergence of numerous
lay ministries and the development of lay involvement in the life
of the parish, much of the work of the parish priest is less “hands
on” and more “supervisory” and “empowering.”
Where once the priest was expected to direct, coordinate, or at
least, be present for almost every activity that was carried out
in the name of the Church, now it is increasingly recognized that
the responsibility and work of building the parish community and
helping it function is shared by many.
The principal
work of the priest as community builder is spiritual. The priest,
therefore, should see his objective as involving primarily the
faith and charity life of those entrusted to his pastoral care.
His specific area of concentration is that of building a faith
community strong enough to live the love of Christ so that the
whole community is permeated with the Spirit of Christ. As a true
priest of the new covenant the priest is expected everywhere and
in all times to be the shepherd of God’s people. With special
love the priest provides the spiritual food necessary for salvation
for those entrusted to his care. Whatever faith community is given
to the priest it is here that he feeds the sheep.
The
Priest: Administrator of the Sacred Mysteries
The third function of the priest is to celebrate the sacred mysteries.
He is to preside at the Eucharist through which the believer participates
in the paschal mystery. It is in this work that the priest most
clearly manifests now the eternal reality of the Kingdom of Christ
in glory. It is precisely as he acts in the person of Christ that
the priest breaks through the bonds that confine this temporal
order and, in a unique and transcendental way, acts in the name,
the power and the person of Christ himself.
Traditionally,
the priest has been called “the dispenser of the mysteries
of God.” Whatever else the priest is, he is the source of
sacramental contact with Christ. The framework within which the
Christian reaches God is a sacramental one. It is the priest who
makes Christ the Savior sacramentally present. The priest celebrates
the sacred mysteries through which the Christ of the Passion and
Resurrection is made really and truly present in our time and
world.
It is the
ordained priest, acting in the person of Christ, who brings about
the Eucharistic Sacrifice (cf. Lumen Gentium, 10). Our Holy Father
writes so clearly about the purpose of the ministerial priesthood
in his encyclical on the Eucharist: “In persona Christi
means more than offering ‘in the name of’ or ‘
in the place of’ Christ. In persona means in specific sacramental
identification with the eternal High Priest who is the author
and principal subject of this sacrifice of his, a sacrifice in
which, in truth, nobody can take his place... The assembly gathered
together for the celebration of the Eucharist, if it is to be
a truly Eucharistic assembly, absolutely requires the presence
of an ordained priest as its president... the community is by
itself incapable of providing an ordained minister... It is the
Bishop who, through the Sacrament of Holy Orders, makes a new
presbyter by conferring upon him the power to consecrate the Eucharist”
(Ecclesia de Eucharistia, 29).
All
Working Together
Our diocese is blessed with so many people who commit themselves
to carrying out the mission of the Church. What is needed now
is a recommitment by lay faithful, religious and ordained ministers
to work together in order that qualified and effective ministry
is guaranteed in sustaining the work of the Church. Since the
mission of the Church is not solely the work of priests but rather
a co-responsibility involving both the ordained and lay faithful,
we recognize this opportunity to explore collaborative approaches
to ministry.
The
Pastoral Ministry of the Church
The Oglebay convocation will begin a process of reflection and
discernment involving the entire diocesan Church about how best
you and I can be Church to one another and for the people of Southwestern
Pennsylvania. We are facing the reality of less priests in this
diocese but less priests does not mean there has to be less ministry.
The pastoral ministry of the Church is, indeed, the primary work
of the priests and bishops who stand in the person of Christ as
head and shepherd. However, the building up of God’s Kingdom
on earth, promoting effective and qualified ministry, sustaining
healthy and vibrant parishes is the work of the entire People
of God.
As the Bishop
of this local Church it is my responsibility to encourage all
of the faithful to live out their vocation in building up the
faith community. In his recent post synodal exhortation on the
ministry of bishops, Pope John Paul II explains: “The duty
of Bishops at the beginning of a new millennium is thus clearly
marked out. It is the same duty as ever: to proclaim the Gospel
of Christ, the salvation of the world. But it is a duty which
has a new urgency and which calls for cooperation and commitment
on the part of the whole People of God. The Bishop needs to be
able to count on the members of his diocesan presbyterate and
on his deacons, the ministers of the Blood of Christ and of charity;
he needs to be able to count on his consecrated sisters and brothers,
called to be for the Church and the world eloquent witnesses of
the primacy of God in the Christian life and the power of his
love amid the frailty of the human condition; and he needs to
be able to count on the lay faithful, whose greater scope for
the apostolate represents for their pastors a source of particular
support and a reason for special comfort” (Pastores Gregis,
74).
A
Call to Work Together
It is in this spirit that I ask the faithful of this local Church
to begin a process of consultation and reflection on how this
diocesan church can best exercise the pastoral ministry of Jesus
Christ in a most effective, competent and joy-filled manner. This
will mean that difficult questions need to be asked and answered,
commitment to undertake responsibilities pursued, that more lay
faithful discover their vocation within the Church, that young
men be open to serving the Church as priests, married couples
to live a prayerful, spiritual life raising children in a truly
domestic church, that single women and men embrace the Christian
vocation, that religious women and men continue their witness
to the Kingdom, and that priests invest time to their own spiritual
life and continuing formation.
A
Dynamic, Living Parish Community
One of the measures of a healthy diocesan Church is the dynamism
of its parishes. In the last sixteen years nearly 25,000 women
and men have been initiated into the Catholic Church in this diocese;
I have ordained over 70 men to the priesthood; tens of thousands
of young people have received the sacrament of confirmation; even
more have been baptized. Where is this faith sustained –
where does one come regularly to meet Christ as Savior and Lord?
For most of the faithful this takes place in the parish.
In his post
synodal exhortation to the Church in America, Pope John Paul II
explains the goal of parish life: “The parish is the privileged
place where the faithful concretely experience the Church... The
parish needs to be constantly renewed on the basis of the principle
that the parish must continue to be above all a Eucharistic community”
(Ecclesia in America, 41).
It is in the
parish that the priest celebrates the sacraments, people are spiritually
nourished and hear the Word, and where the faith community thrives
and grows. Indeed, the experience of faith and spirituality can
be nurtured in many ways but the parish is the normative experience
of Christ’s Church and therefore becomes a central point
of interest for all believers. “The institution of the parish,
thus renewed, can be the source of great hope. It can gather people
in community, assist family life, overcome the sense of anonymity,
welcome people and help them be involved in their neighborhood
and in society” (Ecclesia in America, 41).
Questions
to Guide Our Discernment
Fewer priests does not mean less ministry. As we discern how best
we can sustain and strengthen our parish life with fewer priests
a number of questions can help frame the discussion. For example:
are our liturgies prayerful celebrations fostering full, conscious
and active participation of all people? Do we have all necessary
liturgical ministries including women and men, young and old,
people of various ethnic and racial groups, people with disabilities?
Is our liturgical music participatory? How active are the pastoral
and finance councils? Are they truly collaborative and consultative
bodies? Are there ministries directed to the homebound and hospitalized
as well as those in nursing homes? Are there sufficient numbers
of catechists to sustain a qualified religious education program
for children, adult faith formation, and those seeking full communion
with the Church? What are the ministerial needs of this particular
parish community? In what ministries should the parish invest
its limited resources? Are there ways that parishes can partner
with one another in responding to shared needs? Each of us individually
can also ask ourselves how might I use the gifts God has given
me for the good of my parish community.
We also need
to be aware of the many ecclesial career services that have developed
in recent years in the Church. For example, we have a number of
fulltime parish employees ranging from directors or coordinators
of religious education to business managers, from youth ministers
to directors of music, and maintenance personnel. Almost half
of our parishes have a parochial school and thus employ a principal,
teachers and staff. All of these together form a collaborative
effort to best serve the ministry of the Church within the parish.
At the heart
of the Church is the Eucharist. As the encyclical letter on the
Eucharist teaches us: “When the Church celebrates the Eucharist,
the memorial of her Lord’s death and resurrection, this
central event of salvation becomes really present and ‘the
work of our redemption is carried out’… This is the
faith from which generations of Christians down the ages have
lived” (11). The gift of the Holy Eucharist is what sustains,
fashions and forms the parish community. Without the Eucharist
the faith community is incomplete.
Our Holy Father
also reminds us that: “The People of New Covenant, far from
closing in upon itself, becomes a sacrament for humanity, a sign
and instrument of the salvation achieved by Christ.” Thus
the parish community is involved not only with its own interests
but also the interests of the wider community. The Holy Father
continues: “From the perpetuation of the sacrifice of the
Cross and her communion with the body and blood of Christ in the
Eucharist, the Church draws the spiritual power needed to carry
out her mission. The Eucharist thus appears as both the source
and the summit of all evangelization, since its goal is the communion
of mankind with Christ and in him with the Father and the Holy
Spirit” (Ecclesia de Eucharistia, 22).
Future
Directions
These reflections I offer as an introduction to a process of consultation
that includes in an initial stage the clergy convocation later
this month. The ongoing process will continue in the deaneries
and parishes of this diocese. More information will become available
as we gather and disseminate it through the efforts of your pastor
and in the pages of the Pittsburgh Catholic.
In Spring
2005 I hope to receive recommendations from each deanery on how
best to sustain pastoral ministry in its parishes, institutions,
and faith communities. My intention then would be to share the
fruit of this process in a pastoral letter which will provide
some direction as we move into the future.
In concluding
these reflections I ask for your prayers in this important moment.
In your prayers I ask you to include all of the priests who during
the convocation will begin this journey considering the issues
of effective, qualified ministry needed in our Church today. We
will join you in the prayer that we will be open to the power
of the Spirit who asks all of us to be generous with our gifts,
talents and lives.
This is our
moment. In every age in the life of the Church it has fallen to
the faithful and clergy of that specific time to respond to the
issues and the circumstances of the hour. This is our moment.
These are our circumstances and we need to address them motivated
by faith, guided by the power of the Spirit and directed by the
teaching and received tradition of the Church. Out of this will
come, with God’s grace, a fruitful development that will
only enrich this diocesan Church and those whom we serve now and
in the future.
We can “set
out into the deep” with confidence and courage as we are
challenged by Jesus and reminded by our Holy Father. Whatever
we undertake if we do so with prayerful faith and confident respect
for the mission entrusted to the Church we can succeed. We are
confident of this because it is Christ who walks with us as we
set out into the deep – into the future – filled with
faith, hope and love.
Asking God’s
blessing on this effort to envision ministry for the future and
on all of the faithful of the Church of Pittsburgh, I am
Faithfully
in Christ,

Bishop of
Pittsburgh
September
3, 2004
Saint Gregory the Great
Pope and Doctor